Re: [Caml-list] subtyping and inheritance (bug?)

[Brian Rogoff <bpr@artisan.com>]

Eray Ozkural writes:
> On Tuesday 25 June 2002 05:54, Jacques Garrigue wrote:
> > Sure. The children_set method contains a contravariant occurence of 'self.
> > It cannot be compatible with its subclasses.  You don't need to have
> > mutable data to have variance incompatibilities.
> > No bug, business as usual.
> 
> Which programming style would express the intended semantics, then? I guess we 
> would need a slightly different formulation.

Yes, you need a different formulation. If you want to have a tree class but
want to create a family of color_trees which can be coerced to each other
and put on the same list, something like this 

class ['a] tree =
  object 
    val v = (None : string option)
    val ch = ([] : 'a list)
    method value_get = v
    method value_set x = {< v = x >}
    method children_get = ch
    method children_set x = {< ch = x >}
  end;;

class color_tree =
  object
    inherit [color_tree] tree
    method color = "green"
  end;;

class pine_tree =
  object
    val mutable age = 0.0
    inherit color_tree
    method color = "evergreen"
    method age = age
  end;;

class fake_tree =
  object
    inherit color_tree
    method color = "olivegreen"
    method material = "fantastic plastic"
  end;;

now these can all be coreced to color_tree, and they have a colortree list 
type on method children_get. 

let colortree = new color_tree;;
let pinetree = new pine_tree;;
let faketree = new fake_tree;;

let trees = [colortree; 
	     (pinetree :> color_tree);
	     (faketree :> color_tree)];;

faketree#children_set trees;;

If you create a new class, 

class palm_tree =
  object
    inherit [palm_tree] tree
    method color = "palmgreen"
    method fronds = true
  end;;

then you won't be able to do the coercion. 

let palmtree = new palm_tree;;
(palmtree :> color_tree);; (* ERROR! *)

-- Brian

-------------------
To unsubscribe, mail caml-list-request@inria.fr Archives: http://caml.inria.fr
Bug reports: http://caml.inria.fr/bin/caml-bugs FAQ: http://caml.inria.fr/FAQ/
Beginner's list: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ocaml_beginners