Re: Szabo's Algebra of Proofs

[Tom Leinster <T.Leinster@dpmms.cam.ac.uk>]

I don't know anything about the subject itself, but according to math. review
93a:03062 there's a paper by Barry Jay refuting one of Szabo's claims.  The
paper is `Coherence in category theory and the Church-Rosser property', 
Notre Dame J Formal Logic 33 (1992), no 1, 140-143. 

Tom


Todd Wilson wrote: 
> 
> In the book
> 
>     M. E. Szabo, Algebra of Proofs, Studies in Logic and the
>     Foundations of Mathematics, Vol. 88, North-Holland, 1978.

[...]

> The book itself contains a wealth of technical detail that includes
> many dozens of claims whose proofs are not worked out in detail.  I'm
> writing to ask whether anyone has any knowledge about the degree to
> which this work was refereed and/or whether the results have been
> verified independently.  I'm appealing especially to those who work in
> categorical logic or those interested in automatic proof verification
> in category theory, both of which groups, it would seem, should be
> interested in Szabo's work.