Re: CRM114 Mailfilter and spam.el

[asjo@koldfront.dk (Adam Sjøgren)]

On Fri, 02 Apr 2004 08:22:25 +0200, Kai wrote:

> asjo@koldfront.dk (Adam Sjøgren) writes:
>> * If a spam is misclassified as ham, I would like to mark that
>> message in some way, so that it is moved to nnml:spam and
>> mailfilter.crm is called with --learnspam on it.

> I think you want to set spam-process-ham-in-spam-groups for this
> one.

>> * If a ham is misclassified as spam, and therefore is split into
>> nnml:spam, I would like to move it to the correct group and have
>> mailfilter.crm called on it with --learnnonspam.

> But I can't find spam-process-spam-in-ham-groups. Hm.

Okay, I got it almost working (by reading the documentation one more
time).

My understanding so far is this:

 * I want all my groups to be unclassified - because I only want to
   train on errors (marking them by hand). I never want to train on
   properly classified ham nor spam.

 * On the topic that contains all my normal email-groups, I've set
   these parameters:

    ((spam-process
      '(spam spam-use-crm114))
     (spam-process-destination . "nnml:spam"))

   This means that if spam ends up in one of my normal email-groups, I
   mark it with M-d ($), and it crm114 is called to learn it as spam,
   and it is moved to nnml:spam.

   Success! This is what I want, and it works.

 * On my nnml:spam-group (where spam is split to, and moved to as per
   above) I've set these parameters:

    ((spam-process
      '(ham spam-use-crm114))
     (ham-process-destination . "nnml:normal")
     (spam-process-destination . "nnml:spam")
     (ham-marks
      (gnus-ticked-mark))

   What I want to achieve with this is: When a ham ends up in nnml:spam,
   I tick it (!). When I leave the group, crm114 should learn it as
   ham, and the article should be moved to nnml:normal[1].

   This only works partially: The ticked articles are processed by
   crm114 to be learned as ham (fine), but the articles are not moved
   to nnml:normal - they stay in nnml:spam.

   (I guess the spam-process-destination should be removed, as it
    isn't used).

 * My global variables are set like this:

    (setq
     ; Only process each article once:
     spam-log-to-registry t
     ; Only process spam in nonspam groups (i.e. Train On Error only):
     spam-move-spam-nonspam-groups-only t
     ; All my groups are unclassified, I should remove this one:
     spam-process-ham-in-spam-groups t
     ; Process ham in ham and unclassified groups:
     spam-process-ham-in-nonham-groups t
     ; I want ham to be unread when moved out (it never is, but that's
     ; what I would like if it did move):
     spam-mark-ham-unread-before-move-from-spam-group t
     ; CRM114 Mailfilter (I will submit a patch):
     spam-use-crm114 t
     spam-crm114-path "/home/asjo/crm114.pl" ; (for debugging)
     spam-crm114-database-directory "--fileprefix=/home/asjo/.crm114/")

   And I use (: spam-split) in my fancy split-rules.

This is very cool - it's beginning to make sense to me _and_ it almost
works :-)

I've only got the "ham-marked articles in nnml:spam should be moved as
well as processed"-problem left.


  Best regards,

    Adam

[1]: If the articles I mark as ham in nnml:spam could be 1) learned as
     ham by crm114 and then 2) respooled, that would be even better
     than 2) moved to nnml:normal.

-- 
 "Mr. Cotton's... parrot. Same question."                     Adam Sjøgren
                                                         asjo@koldfront.dk