Niklas Morberg <niklas.morberg@axis.com> writes:

> Kevin Greiner <kgreiner@xpediantsolutions.com> writes:
>
>>> 1. Start with two unread and undownloaded messages in a
>>>    group.
>>>
>>> 2. Read the first message.
>>>
>>
>> Niklas, pls do the following command at this point:
>> M-: (debug-on-entry 'gnus-agent-expire)
>> M-: (setq gnus-verbose 7)
>>
>>> 3. Move the second message to another group with `B m'
>>>    without reading it.
>>
>> You should have been thrown into the debugger.  Did that happen?  
>
> Yes.
>
>> Was the first argument to gnus-agent-expire a list of one
>> integer; the article # of the article being moved?
>
> Yes. Complete output:
>
> * gnus-agent-expire((8673) "incoming" force)
>   gnus-request-move-article(8673 "incoming" "mailse01.axis.se" (gnus-request-accept-article "INBOX" (quote nil) t t) t)
>   gnus-summary-move-article(nil)
> * call-interactively(gnus-summary-move-article)
>
>> Type 'c' to continue.
>
> Once again, I end up in the debugger. I hit 'c' again.
>
>> Take a look at the message buffer.  gnus-agent-expire should have
>> printed messages telling you that it removed the NOV entry for the
>> article in question.  Did it?
>
> No. The contents of the message buffer (after having exited
> and re-entered the "incoming" group says):
>
> Moving to INBOX: (8673)...
> Loading gnus-dup...done
> Entering debugger...
>  [2 times]
> Mark set [2 times]
> iswitchb-read-buffer: Quit
> Continuing.
> Expiring articles in incoming
> gnus-agent-expire: Loading overview... Done
> gnus-agent-expire: Sorting entries... Done
> gnus-agent-expire: Merging entries... Done
> Expiry...done
> Entering debugger...
>  [2 times]
> Mark set [2 times]
> Continuing.
> nnimap: Setting marks in INBOX...done
> nnimap: Updating info for INBOX...done
> nnimap: Setting marks in incoming...done
> Retrieving newsgroup: incoming...
> nnimap: Updating info for incoming...done
> Fetching headers for incoming...done
> Generating summary...done
> No more unread articles
>
>>> 4. Exit the group.
>>>
>>> 5. Re-enter the same group. The second message shows up in
>>>    the summary buffer, but it not possible to look at it.
>>>    It has not been downloaded and it is not on the server.
>>>
>>> This only happens if gnus-agent-mark-unread-after-downloaded
>>> is nil. Setting g-a-m-u-a-d to non-nil makes the problem go
>>> away.
>>
>> You should be using revision 6.142, or later, of
>> gnus-agent.el. Are you?
>
> Yup:
>
> $ cvs status gnus-agent.el
> ===================================================================
> File: gnus-agent.el     Status: Up-to-date
>
>    Working revision:    6.142
>    Repository revision: 6.142   /usr/local/cvsroot/gnus/lisp/gnus-agent.el,v
>    Sticky Tag:          (none)
>    Sticky Date:         (none)
>    Sticky Options:      (none)
>
> Before doing the steps above I disabled all spam
> functionality, exited emacs, downloaded a fresh gnus from
> CVS, built it, installed it and then started emacs.
>
> Niklas

Niklas,

The problem is that gnus-agent-expire failed to expire the
article. That shouldn't happen when the third parameter is force.  It
implies that either g-a-e is broken or that 8673 was never fetched
into the agent.  I've attached a copy of just g-a-e from revision
6.136 as I've been concerned with some recent changes to it.  Either
append this file to your gnus-agent.el or load it AFTER opening a
group.  Once you've loaded it, set gnus-verbose to 7 and repeat the 
'B m' test.