Crosspost Nannies: Positions now available

Crosspost Nannies: Positions now available

[Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen]

One of the most annoying Usenet phenomena currently is massive, yet
stupid, crossposts.  I don't know what to do to help remedy this
problem exactly, but one possibility is to try to educate people about
what they're doing.  Most people don't know that they are
crossposting, and would rather not have if they knew about it.  (There
are some morons who find gratuitous crossposting funny, but they are
in definite minority.)

So here's my idea:  Start educating people who crosspost to your
favourite group.  It doesn't take much work -- just tap `S M-c' and
then `y' whenever you see an inappropriate crosspost.  This will send
off a polite notifier to the person who did the crosspost.  (If the
article hasn't been crossposted, the `S M-c' command won't send a
complaint.  The command understands the process/prefix convention.)

I've been doing this for a couple of days in alt.religion.emacs, and I
haven't gotten any hate mail back -- just a few apologetic notes
from people swearing never to crosspost again.  

I think it's important that these notification should be sent in a
timely fashion.  If the article is more than one day old, it's
probably not a good idea to send a notification.  There should
probably be just one person in each group to nanny it -- receiving
multiple notifications will probably make people feel like they're
being harassed.  Perhaps one could set up a register of people who are
nannying groups?  

So -- if you think this is a good idea, give it a whirl.  It won't
make the crossposting plague go away right away, but I think with time
it may help alleviate the problem.

-- 
  "Yes.  The journey through the human heart 
     would have to wait until some other time."

Re: Crosspost Nannies: Positions now available

[Sten Drescher]

>>>>> Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen writes:

LMI> So here's my idea: Start educating people who crosspost to your
LMI> favourite group.  It doesn't take much work -- just tap `S M-c'
LMI> and then `y' whenever you see an inappropriate crosspost.  This
LMI> will send off a polite notifier to the person who did the
LMI> crosspost.  (If the article hasn't been crossposted, the `S M-c'
LMI> command won't send a complaint.  The command understands the
LMI> process/prefix convention.)

	Can this be tuned to not send a complaint if it's cross posted
to less than N groups?  Cross posts are good, in moderation, so I
wouldn't want us to be encouraging posting the same article multiple
times, but I'd agree that I've rarely, if ever, seen a message that
should be cross posted to more than 5 groups.

-- 
+----------------------  Tivoli Customer Support  ----------------------+
|   Sten Drescher                     Tivoli Systems, Inc               |
|   email: sten.drescher@tivoli.com   9442 Capital of Texas Hwy North   |
|   phone: (512) 794-9070             Arboretum Plaza One, Suite 500    |
|   fax  : (512) 345-2784             Austin, Texas 78759               |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------+

Re: Crosspost Nannies: Positions now available

[Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen]

Sten Drescher <sten.drescher@tivoli.com> writes:

> 	Can this be tuned to not send a complaint if it's cross posted
> to less than N groups?  Cross posts are good, in moderation, so I
> wouldn't want us to be encouraging posting the same article multiple
> times, but I'd agree that I've rarely, if ever, seen a message that
> should be cross posted to more than 5 groups.

Well, you have to inspect the crosspost visually first in any case and
press `y' to actually send the complaint off...

-- 
  "Yes.  The journey through the human heart 
     would have to wait until some other time."