How to Message-ID in citation-line

How to Message-ID in citation-line

[Guillermo Antonio Amaral Bastidas]

 Hi fellow gnus,

 Does anybody know how one could go about getting the Message-ID
into the insert-citation-line, I do know I need to write a function,
but I lack relevant examples to analyze.

 I am looking for something like this:

  "In message <MESSAGE-ID> E-MAIL (FULL NAME) wrote:"

 Maybe somebody can point me to the right direction :-)

 Cheers,
gamaral

-- 
Guillermo Antonio Amaral Bastidas (gamaral)
  Free/Libre/Open-Source Software Advocate & KDE Developer
  http://blog.guillermoamaral.com/

Re: How to Message-ID in citation-line

[Joachim Reiter]

Hello,

* Am 31.10.2007 23:27 tat Guillermo Antonio Amaral Bastidas dies kund:
>  Hi fellow gnus,

>  Does anybody know how one could go about getting the Message-ID
> into the insert-citation-line, I do know I need to write a function,
> but I lack relevant examples to analyze.

>  I am looking for something like this:

>   "In message <MESSAGE-ID> E-MAIL (FULL NAME) wrote:"

>  Maybe somebody can point me to the right direction :-)

In my mind, these you want, makes a two line citation... This is many
and looks like a novel :-(

Sorry for this bad english

Greetings... Joachim

Re: How to Message-ID in citation-line

[Guillermo Antonio Amaral Bastidas]

Joachim Reiter <Spam@hobbyecke-pc.de> writes:

> Hello,
>
> In my mind, these you want, makes a two line citation... This is many
> and looks like a novel :-(
>
> Sorry for this bad english
>

Hi Joachim,

  Some times it does, I just like the way it looks. :-)

  I might not use it in the end, but I would still like to learn more about
_gnus_ and how something like this could be accomplished.

-- 
Guillermo Antonio Amaral Bastidas (gamaral)
  Free/Libre/Open-Source Software Advocate & KDE Developer
  http://blog.guillermoamaral.com/

Re: How to Message-ID in citation-line

[Joachim Reiter]

Hello,

* At 01.11.2007 00:21 Guillermo Antonio Amaral Bastidas wrote:
> Joachim Reiter <Spam@hobbyecke-pc.de> writes:

>> Hello,

>> In my mind, these you want, makes a two line citation... This is many
>> and looks like a novel :-(

>> Sorry for this bad english


> Hi Joachim,

>   Some times it does, I just like the way it looks. :-)

>   I might not use it in the end, but I would still like to learn more about
> _gnus_ and how something like this could be accomplished.

OK... So sorry for my comment, because I also want to hear many to learn
more ;-) and sorry I cannot give you some help

Greetings... Joachim

Re: How to Message-ID in citation-line

[Reiner Steib]

On Wed, Oct 31 2007, Guillermo Antonio Amaral Bastidas wrote:

>  Does anybody know how one could go about getting the Message-ID
> into the insert-citation-line, [...]

Please don't.  Quoting myself:

,----[ <http://article.gmane.org/gmane.emacs.gnus.general/64883> ]
| Personally, I think adding the MID in the citation line is completely
| useless.  In contrast to name, mail address or date this information
| _is_ already present in the reply/followup anyhow (References or
| In-Reply-To header).
| 
| The only reason that it is common is that it's the stupid default of
| Outlook Express making the citation line exceedingly wide or wrapped
| in two lines ("citation novel" instead of citation _line_; In the de.*
| hierarchy, you'll soon get flamed if you'd use of such citation novel).
`----

Bye, Reiner.
-- 
       ,,,
      (o o)
---ooO-(_)-Ooo---  |  PGP key available  |  http://rsteib.home.pages.de/

Re: How to Message-ID in citation-line

[Guillermo Antonio Amaral Bastidas]

Reiner Steib <reinersteib+gmane@imap.cc> writes:

> Please don't.  Quoting myself:
>
> ,----[ <http://article.gmane.org/gmane.emacs.gnus.general/64883> ]
> | Personally, I think adding the MID in the citation line is completely
> | useless.  In contrast to name, mail address or date this information
> | _is_ already present in the reply/followup anyhow (References or
> | In-Reply-To header).
> | 
> | The only reason that it is common is that it's the stupid default of
> | Outlook Express making the citation line exceedingly wide or wrapped
> | in two lines ("citation novel" instead of citation _line_; In the de.*
> | hierarchy, you'll soon get flamed if you'd use of such citation novel).
> `----
>
> Bye, Reiner.

Hi Reiner,

 Outlook ewww.  -- Now you made me feel dirty.

-- 
Guillermo Antonio Amaral Bastidas (gamaral)
  Free/Libre/Open-Source Software Advocate & KDE Developer
  http://blog.guillermoamaral.com/

Re: How to Message-ID in citation-line

[David Z Maze]

Joachim Reiter <Spam@hobbyecke-pc.de> writes:

> * At 01.11.2007 00:21 Guillermo Antonio Amaral Bastidas wrote:
>>   I might not use it in the end, but I would still like to learn more about
>> _gnus_ and how something like this could be accomplished.
>
> OK... So sorry for my comment, because I also want to hear many to learn
> more ;-) and sorry I cannot give you some help

If I was going to put this together, I'd write a custom citation
function and set message-citation-line-function to point to it.  Within
that function, it looks like, I can call things like
(message-fetch-reply-field "Message-ID") to get things from the original
message.

  --dzm

Re: How to Message-ID in citation-line

[Joachim Reiter]

Hello,

* At 01.11.2007 16:41 tat David Z. Maze wrote:
> Joachim Reiter <Spam@hobbyecke-pc.de> writes:

>> * At 01.11.2007 00:21 Guillermo Antonio Amaral Bastidas wrote:
>>>   I might not use it in the end, but I would still like to learn more about
>>> _gnus_ and how something like this could be accomplished.

>> OK... So sorry for my comment, because I also want to hear many to learn
>> more ;-) and sorry I cannot give you some help

> If I was going to put this together, I'd write a custom citation
> function and set message-citation-line-function to point to it.  Within
> that function, it looks like, I can call things like
> (message-fetch-reply-field "Message-ID") to get things from the original
> message.

:-) Thx for this Info...
But I dont mean exactly problems with M-ID when I want to hear many to
learn, I mean all within Emacs and/or Gnus ;-)

If you look at me, sometimes I look maybe like a sponge, absorb all I can
learn *g*

Again sorry for this (my) not so good english

Greetings... (sponge)Joachim