From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Return-Path: X-Spam-Checker-Version: SpamAssassin 3.4.0 (2014-02-07) on aws-us-west-2-korg-lkml-1.web.codeaurora.org X-Spam-Level: X-Spam-Status: No, score=-0.5 required=3.0 tests=DKIM_ADSP_CUSTOM_MED, DKIM_INVALID,DKIM_SIGNED,FREEMAIL_FORGED_FROMDOMAIN,FREEMAIL_FROM, HEADER_FROM_DIFFERENT_DOMAINS,MAILING_LIST_MULTI,SPF_PASS,URIBL_BLOCKED autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no version=3.4.0 Received: from mail.kernel.org (mail.kernel.org [198.145.29.99]) by smtp.lore.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTP id 55408C43381 for ; Sat, 9 Mar 2019 06:52:13 +0000 (UTC) Received: from krantz.zx2c4.com (krantz.zx2c4.com [192.95.5.69]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by mail.kernel.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 90DE6207E0 for ; Sat, 9 Mar 2019 06:52:12 +0000 (UTC) Authentication-Results: mail.kernel.org; dkim=fail reason="signature verification failed" (2048-bit key) header.d=gmail.com header.i=@gmail.com header.b="MiNqxSln" DMARC-Filter: OpenDMARC Filter v1.3.2 mail.kernel.org 90DE6207E0 Authentication-Results: mail.kernel.org; dmarc=fail (p=none dis=none) header.from=gmail.com Authentication-Results: mail.kernel.org; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=wireguard-bounces@lists.zx2c4.com Received: from krantz.zx2c4.com (localhost [IPv6:::1]) by krantz.zx2c4.com (ZX2C4 Mail Server) with ESMTP id 459f436e; Sat, 9 Mar 2019 06:41:22 +0000 (UTC) Received: from krantz.zx2c4.com (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by krantz.zx2c4.com (ZX2C4 Mail Server) with ESMTP id 3730f512 for ; Sat, 9 Mar 2019 06:41:18 +0000 (UTC) Received: from mail-wm1-x32d.google.com (mail-wm1-x32d.google.com [IPv6:2a00:1450:4864:20::32d]) by krantz.zx2c4.com (ZX2C4 Mail Server) with ESMTP id dcd99e89 for ; Sat, 9 Mar 2019 06:41:18 +0000 (UTC) Received: by mail-wm1-x32d.google.com with SMTP id e74so14376176wmg.3 for ; Fri, 08 Mar 2019 22:52:07 -0800 (PST) DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmail.com; s=20161025; h=subject:to:references:from:openpgp:autocrypt:message-id :disposition-notification-to:date:user-agent:mime-version :in-reply-to:content-language:content-transfer-encoding; bh=QajY8OUMRl1fNwBty5wep4ZUL3MF3wRGBe9uWukNgt4=; b=MiNqxSlnv6zKp3ofmknqR4rJeX7l0Bk8iDhtXc8Lof29Fk1/vHEd+KofGgcZrE53Y/ lGaZCHhj7aQCIvRpUYUC42XbrdsiNDNNotHlFS17mpiYBlE0Iz8RLQDC9zknJY51LLjl 0CzgNJRqzed7ap2qs3hYW+qmAcDX2bKXvK6blXVmjwXZ8eL189NKKuuoI+eB5Fq7W1e5 PUEqodKqG4O5y9MZxdn1mNjxKRqy7zaTnZPYIzIh4I5sjNlUV2XM1fTvdfcvrVbUnMsv HDxf2Y+SBQ3oSjYYatGyZP08RZ60sjgMDcqdO2eZsVvSxh/o6YYfDF5YLA+uLzg5B0K9 NZ/w== X-Google-DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20161025; h=x-gm-message-state:subject:to:references:from:openpgp:autocrypt :message-id:disposition-notification-to:date:user-agent:mime-version :in-reply-to:content-language:content-transfer-encoding; bh=QajY8OUMRl1fNwBty5wep4ZUL3MF3wRGBe9uWukNgt4=; b=mLV8RXzOUF6mmRuXv2Oc4PyIS9VTUQNLctc3KTdQ3Mjkev/d1sw9VWZjz3Eze+Ckwq MSMrHXRfWM9zirtNoY4tiiQwJDtRapikn7VBPuhCFnPIGsk8rWYp7Uvd5Dvd/bfa5PLU V+ihfKIRBLWe7VeqeDQcxy2XmaLqVOl/TwoV7Ntw9/7vLW7pEXlGB97naA3utfCqbpxS bY4zWLMMZtnMIx4NwZT08cdvGEo1i+FI8xw/NNok9D2C2TQzbeX8jN8WzgJr/dbAd5Ey 6fGE4mXYZrjUQE/1GWGbcnWz/dzDUGBLCxSC0QInNnxhNOitSl3N8hX8d0Ay/X01N++6 RqYg== X-Gm-Message-State: APjAAAXkRN/6lUtlZu3SIHuHrdhsRzg6nsWy+jR2S+g12DY6Hzl50geZ cGKtmfN2tnAeK/Z6wTdUXkD4GbnC X-Google-Smtp-Source: APXvYqz8VIEURZGqxs9HSF5MOTnKqaobtWU7KR4INJDDEUJ/3r4u1uiYIgeh+IoMDs6RpmlWD6HucQ== X-Received: by 2002:a1c:3b06:: with SMTP id i6mr11149026wma.55.1552114325975; Fri, 08 Mar 2019 22:52:05 -0800 (PST) Received: from ?IPv6:2001:470:6aa2:a0::30? (tornado.nanhome.exbit.io. [2001:470:6aa2:a0::30]) by smtp.gmail.com with ESMTPSA id y20sm14298261wra.51.2019.03.08.22.52.04 for (version=TLS1_2 cipher=ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 bits=128/128); Fri, 08 Mar 2019 22:52:05 -0800 (PST) Subject: Re: Master's thesis about VPN performance featuring WireGuard To: wireguard@lists.zx2c4.com References: From: Aaron Jones Openpgp: id=97D58E607188C8C986481CB76A2F898000519052; url=https://keybase.io/aaronmdjones/key.asc Autocrypt: addr=aaronmdjones@gmail.com; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= mQINBFedLrkBEADBntJKJ+0hk3NzXOqWKh27ftm81NSBzZdYwlheZ5M7wGNwUrpHFzyPmgwe 0tU7+J+F3IEOpjWTwYC3ELVQfZ/R5/rJa1iVZf+PGyom7E6DskgaZoIsYfNECPL625MsKAOH M613gZZ0jXadOdyn4jFl6ZmiockkpJZdY8GhXUwrqtoxRgRwXrWS0/2V7D1Ky98ttfZN1juS pdOyzSWT7KzZnULg1Wx9t5gx6jdckQNKxkko2RGTy8DKTPHeOLDdtsShISog8ryLFJQwANnX /WezuB5wrABNit8NmnBAXAM9S10MmvgOyoMZkymUfcjwKLSjWMvV5g7Dgav6tZRxpcCtGtTf l3sqJ143yEdj7RoB2qtoIPr7IBvHRB4aYi0z11q0MitC7dAK4nqwG9wNCx9oYF0PqKCcdIBy f/arn5gci4iI207sn8kMvZKgRnMDxPs7I22Zd6Vu6KcIHk+PLOQ42d1lvKUWcMWgvwKLOimR ujMwTYuuNw2MPZT3cbpxjGj90NrCcXGMikovnYeEkLWvCO0KtayBjiWVznCrskobZ9n6RPAi FeT8XEBr0reMWApyvW6JuXNHF5rMm2ZROOSd6kcXnUWa7SZgYFUf1VB8odb2iBc7Dz3xYk9s tplJTFcbGsLIPwgIC4/Nfu88B4xwNHgIyvFlpEaJvRnr6TaNtQARAQABtCRBYXJvbiBKb25l cyA8YWFyb25tZGpvbmVzQGdtYWlsLmNvbT6JAjgEEwECACIFAledRecCGwEGCwkIBwMCBhUI AgkKCwQWAgMBAh4BAheAAAoJEGoviYAAUZBSiIUQAKJNDJ6VIpfBc9SyH0iU5B1U4rE9XXJN ut/6SoLNbOaYmPAvVZ4ucqSWkOwRCvcaMJgJLUGNSokMojYbSIz/AdqOMUW0mlOlAzyf7jzp gWP0rJWm9yIpLVQ2KIDiyIBFSk0wtofZTuOIj4nRUEdgun3isqADG+wKldgiC1puAArLhrF4 jKVHxhrXt3Uqpp9KMt/9lisHITYkf1Z0QIMpN51Uz664g5Kzr7E8Irdc7KhGuY8I9GA4Kc11 2finujTi0YmY8vmjysMt0OU6KHhOfP3YD17tjr0PijOxQEVYotO62Za9XfcSblXTlM7+8TOR bvOszY1dqXRQ5yON7OSuIMt1p42HyK6fdid1v5653hWhsxOwcKGTJuhP6R48+y6mdMSGflRR 2z9WfCyNlAOjPOJV9WFvbnwq5S/5qOuoYulDhFmPVGkUszklrfxQZVxM83++qpVddszpFQvv FMZAgU1AGgXV59ozxyy6GZJL7ejSaThW6mgHkxAATEioCmTmGAQqjtiGr6PLXgsEXZjKr4RG CFlxWBrNXFrTTeytLui6NjNGdJB4jj75/SKQ5KKe4WBoxJJUgVlRwMQ6yCedNkcZDuE7EIeg 02GS1QVFY9So0Pm17ZkZddljW/jBRw8bbdVssCHTHfOCD6TLHqKS9lFMdwD4xt/7Wu/x64Gh gJI2uQINBFlHMkYBEAC66i1VpMrOL9S+g7pbSBz+ww8rzgWsIqFg3DCV9TcSQjUMRaGH/a7L D1FJL5rInCuhI5/HHCQD8FAY6Izj3QQir7gv9VdiE6ejUPPpAy4hh7BEgvKxUxtWSLN0bnN1 pF7eCBPBFg4yFFMQQtCg8W8NeGfn8jaKPCD7XbPBrEeWpz7RL++x2CGtUh0SJKS6Rko04IcM vguJO3lRrloYQEuBEyumIhJSc4uRu/TNvBhPKVdD+XU2LMITwEOelVB2WXDQjMJqBp/ds+tD kLz4PipsbZAmjuVks5UI+A3nyHWMivnZYYDcvRUsyBSwoyFl8hiz0UZP6X4PFQoQ6o0AIyGp N+7f2ggUaZHVp/pWVvHpMUGzIqMQTrntX+5et8+UKZSwkMirJRZuod6dp6w+o08ijelHYEAw IUslmsmvKRfbZXriDMz7WSjfspqg59fIAJWSFSuHY6LnJ3SGOb1+HWBnao1JcWTikjtoiTf+ EY4SQKiBPeXNp0peIOz/l7rqS570umHt0U1ZFCcoxgXgwsA3mpaIQO65fIK8yzoc9DB/cBPZ kc0DRxmXuzSVceGQegLd25vfXXGs1iC6QsRFZmNNM0WW3w4L9Q/PFZW+N/s4cgaWcSExb7ja 1IO8d1nkc09JuXfbCtFFj2+bIT9bngfSE/wN4hhweg7p4z6xi5vdjQARAQABiQREBBgBCAAP BQJZRzJGAhsCBQkB77QAAikJEGoviYAAUZBSwV0gBBkBCAAGBQJZRzJGAAoJEIrwc3SIqzAS UbMP/jmmIesZjdaSbSTvC8NJtxvHmb6cntDB/UUvxdNxWaFKrrd7/+jNpZDDnDSkOhWRRX61 S0yxx2BxJgQRP+vOpUpqlMseNog7bf6dVGPyV8iNyMb+xYEScNyK3na1G+HpU8rX9ug4iaA7 JZYlX7UmEvom4dh8uA2O7edMo80yY8Ulp1sMTddFO0dbbp7M2cc9QgRdhVpvMrr7adn28pBc /hYv4UyKtQJHzCZksfu+NDHHRcZiDIwd/ma+lv20HNNlj8M+cZO61v9M1CFPdzln0iwR36Rz zl8T1cqvac8L6C8aaox74AQWzG89Oes/IuVjB2Pjj4MmGoDLRJ21prsqfAI7l59/S1KWzRDK R5BmU4fkGeaj0QMNiUSUQZIlEeLGKU7Is+HIKGKodIAbe4qe9QhaF2ohwOFgfBgCXwa0KJjU 4oPlINZdixk8rQarIvwExJ1YlJS4i2P9tMaZT6MbK6OvNCTtIsu6KiG3exIR6cPVxcb13L66 4S9tL83EwcOlqLFNDHWfgGCkNvLXsHmfAB0l+usXSOSwEujk0DGqSfV4me28JOLXqWmSns60 gXXXJrQaTrXE8KYke4Yn9APoD9SfUwt8lj3r4qF0rcV4YOv5msETjeihHQTgiFXNPFrY/X+A RWmLyhoGxCTaCdwbB+rZ5W5uyC8KfQYmWbqF+ziMsxcQAKAuD+MBrfuEdb6csZDACh4IzS7B Vo984GuQ48BoJ5yx9HyV5EmX8ALzMCg1y/UTkwvV+zQt631C9RUBuwGtbSoTgN0eTNwJbkSx TjGWRSSrzTaojv8XipSR6wJHx0ngSrU8n7n7SayhkYkaEA6E29lTt6vJNGAKk0obEOTKXJIp Y+Q6FrTIj3FvD0e0mmQdz2RDc3nH+UsbhnJros/cntmEeb4lmxJqD4yt9reHSnZtCBmCW00n hvcEag+xTF2N7P87mkvXTFzohMRm0qWcIjh97PNYFQTTRSiH6Hs7iIUYsWNIyg10b3L+bYC+ +IJjaHUqSR0M199xPUCH8Ji4ea7MJ1nKry6RbAYpk9GB4xxn5peVHvehesKL+LiOWcBbyoG2 pX144MJhesCd3K2RDuI3hiNtkRuxFJwHWOKJEsAYqfSPEHGynLXbgwwqJM6yFldBzhVrmLjC BmspojEVxmkF3wBVyz3RLuhGxsTyGiQYA+GR5zzOk0uqLEcfwebAvHvv28Mj/dHwXLGhmHgZ o345T6xYKMQGCaHaFDpXM2M0bBiMama6ggwb5xM0/unv8AOCtTy1JO2v0DqzDfEO+xXdiWX1 MWwLiSh1Fg1xDvGRs/jo/mh6Tv5qZJbkd6slf8412J2wsWqKCsJorZfT8s3l6F78mT5WAiEz yUfHgfEYiQREBBgBCAAPAhsCBQJZRzaNBQkD0j1FAinBXSAEGQEIAAYFAllHMkYACgkQivBz dIirMBJRsw/+OaYh6xmN1pJtJO8Lw0m3G8eZvpye0MH9RS/F03FZoUqut3v/6M2lkMOcNKQ6 FZFFfrVLTLHHYHEmBBE/686lSmqUyx42iDtt/p1UY/JXyI3Ixv7FgRJw3IredrUb4elTytf2 6DiJoDslliVftSYS+ibh2Hy4DY7t50yjzTJjxSWnWwxN10U7R1tunszZxz1CBF2FWm8yuvtp 2fbykFz+Fi/hTIq1AkfMJmSx+740McdFxmIMjB3+Zr6W/bQc02WPwz5xk7rW/0zUIU93OWfS LBHfpHPOXxPVyq9pzwvoLxpqjHvgBBbMbz056z8i5WMHY+OPgyYagMtEnbWmuyp8AjuXn39L UpbNEMpHkGZTh+QZ5qPRAw2JRJRBkiUR4sYpTsiz4cgoYqh0gBt7ip71CFoXaiHA4WB8GAJf BrQomNTig+Ug1l2LGTytBqsi/ATEnViUlLiLY/20xplPoxsro680JO0iy7oqIbd7EhHpw9XF xvXcvrrhL20vzcTBw6WosU0MdZ+AYKQ28teweZ8AHSX66xdI5LAS6OTQMapJ9XiZ7bwk4tep aZKezrSBddcmtBpOtcTwpiR7hif0A+gP1J9TC3yWPevioXStxXhg6/mawRON6KEdBOCIVc08 Wtj9f4BFaYvKGgbEJNoJ3BsH6tnlbm7ILwp9BiZZuoX7OIwJEGoviYAAUZBSxkMP/3f2arpN z6dLYHCaM/0Qd0F12Wx5YGOp2CnIawWJp/ymQTXwpMyZB6WiZpUHcw9EzRoLmsZEjVPIG4od Txdxtxgo+iYnt6zJ37pZCYc/etLbDs2bXvqdHNDXuBqxTz7IV1/Dq6K0sGTXBKflKrgbITbk U4JlZBElKtrWTAu7WxePiIHtQT9DyWfllDXBsKrGlfaAs4aymP5FRZoA1581V1H0AfGvplTR qwKCHzE4nS+kapl1zMP37Vqd1T+BUjBwRQhDTcIdf7766cDq9eURa/fX7XX6T41vjLAr2XbK SjQUyGG0eD6HckjN7JpsUPGiUey3ho5eJhWHKtR+8lt5TwgRwzK6C4JLOU4rXRr+7Gn+De2p sTzSf/8W2FBr03J3o24b7l5XzCYJExjqFnAmSbuuzQVKM+vtI2i+BBM9Pive4wWAlxz4Dn/J ahCd66N8gChtoDJWyGWQD6CNofe52DA12dEVUAJgSQDA4Ib2R6E5N6oqGpZvwZM+S8OBYbag qxvmlDtTwELBCr7tVYz4gLHXcBfEh1fU3NECrZiye8boRAV0IysnO4U8U+NQh9SvTnR7fkbj GFrcyfVtp4aNhkeGADoWNtJCl6AlsgNkT2Zcgm1Us5FQdL3h5NQF6VO0GGmCRpNTEWEtYYIy dlfFzlV2i87aJNRjIs1ZwiYkuIxTuQINBFlHM6EBEADAvl9iatEY3MZORRxC3rBhSNWXfLnz kpvK54DzyQ9wxh6JXoGE6pfV9yG1b+cFZcprnuXK8DIJXnX1cxxsZ9jnnqt8mnd8aJF17iBg diukE2JpXXGYygWq8bnOFKxmDjnQ/ZfMgjuXn/9vPRJ4MhINvgEkGBwxTQcOVIGnOYnbCrjC wcgBFGkdKNiEN7gBfyiUTby2x6tBGTvb/FmVook/Z94AZsroolkoF06Pb0GPzHSekWgKUCoN K1FQXTx56yO9j5xt/lK/TSSEhDeGad2xbhQFV64KK6c403hF6NseAo0B7UmuJ49NTRg6MKuE OYsqs6QFwNVKoJYXmX4Nlee5gIiNbVar3dzaIx8fBq7Esb6sm2B8zmFj0ae6nUN2r+CdtLUk J48ANA1/ACPeeeFuUPrYt0f6MRgFv4EgxdahVXBkspSiiT+C4QSAs4G8rH8+mviOh4AI8cUl cVF5qbr3vnjqsWHPvZyv/rjQI3ajafzjO916DjokwPyB7cKlfemMnhMhYIu1BLDnQz6Yx5ok hXAuVHwyscTlOBHJd1879qF2hF2bar1jLVbuWjGRbhRzywTNrxlxU1MEEU/tarHH9FLLB5BZ eayGPcsmLCKp4lpfOhq2VSwzhMFa+rDhvlrJfG9PS/PCQRQR47tQTCuJ63TBw6/tPxep+myf 7/3srwARAQABiQIlBBgBCAAPBQJZRzOhAhsMBQkB77QAAAoJEGoviYAAUZBSxaUP/1sJ1Vg4 0doTwQtJr/iej3Dx2EndABp5LgyLyDJCODlUM5VSYrOI11TWDdsDs1pkTTxBoa+G0goZcHWs fkrLUlSf3Vh3LHX8oe+CMh/HrMt8Sf1YjIxz1Lc+ZDL8NaRY0f1s0lX8XMoCwbBu0mcbscN1 utc7xLu0sjpUn257NKIhMTE0tQABdo0thnbJMSrNalAk9M3arTo8/EugLPKw7UQfanimqzFI nBZIxEfhZ16pCzcSyf3WriXf1AbkoE4I4UV4pau6sy44VsPiVsxmNUDr27yAOB1R4KV+4oY6 j0nKMYsjk9trhVhFed08153GRsnd/k9ztkgvAsxwh6BnKYLF/Db3BxEkTQwgdayUmsOPCnqd aJVVRmWyRtSB3ZfhjQ9G0le6QPO325H9UUQ4RPnOgdwEEAzEkGVKO66DRkfWXIKZjszFEDuc RRJfsdLND7kZBFBeoAhrmm++jzLLa8j470jrywPqASUtisVrVnKwjb/3WKblWF7woFPHvRhJ BYz2c4QH4EuGIggW8AxExr9e1cdteTs/2+5E67vkWnMaJcTeQybxrh7GEGw0JxsRkKqP/PQx bIc5eZZJ0FigQqJkOGNvv8OZAmwzLXf6F1r2200g58/L9H53Vrw3ppocMbVN2yryR78qTqRZ kd+SWyQgBNScj2MSoCJOxKYbH1+xiQIlBBgBCAAPAhsMBQJZRzaUBQkD0jvxAAoJEGoviYAA UZBSLnAQAI9lAq/WgTYvdHZsy8Zvd3SKQ+0FDJPb8K75UYV5dnsVq1eRybXXStWieuSYq+XB J5KAcnlrz8yygPVFc5OLZit4XeYeAsXnCp5JWfDjcd/c+wnYvqgOv3m330cxdsDt0mkj1BK0 dqnkx5r49Zw7VTGlCnPFiJRUbho2DihwC6r6ys9aAejt7AhqcXv6w3mztjfperGeN9hICOI3 6G3uLgmUmx2z3pedpKPWDNwKWKI0zE+B6yNLENN10PGSJjHMM5nil7ILoqZ40Awg/+nZgJCB 1FYDgbI5NQvhN24Uoh8Wz5EV9CtXg2bDoPi8MRIBkV9oJU48Te5wFuM2uoppPLOon2z29zsV kNOzqQ7jIUf6iZkoQV3j4X7EES5cfPYt+r2082BR7FPuk4oJQHja2uoZatxi3NNAyR3+Nj7V O9ZDz6vZ7Cm3tBtJFJnCOGdDvsQ/zsOYkqXSfY0hq0I2Qm3JVqCICxom+2qlBN16lpteJnwX zo4QFfy7qazxzc9ra1FV6N0xzdUbT0hWPzgV4vlvsAqB18IZEgl5TlJqo7LmcHUUndc43pbH HcvbbT16z0XnTl1tpgthVl8MhX+FdGEDqLEJzmExLMnmvNhn/UwXpjxFCjkfpK2U25y2OyR5 uU7wjkV1U8cPmP7M7xHchPfSRDMU0ThX8hT4Xw3rbm/N Message-ID: <08c7ef00-1e08-3f4c-8be8-731e16abfcd1@gmail.com> Date: Sat, 9 Mar 2019 06:52:02 +0000 User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:60.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/60.5.1 MIME-Version: 1.0 In-Reply-To: Content-Language: en-GB X-BeenThere: wireguard@lists.zx2c4.com X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.15 Precedence: list List-Id: Development discussion of WireGuard List-Unsubscribe: , List-Archive: List-Post: List-Help: List-Subscribe: , Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Errors-To: wireguard-bounces@lists.zx2c4.com Sender: "WireGuard" -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA512 On 05/03/2019 16:37, Paul Emmerich wrote: > Hi, > > > one of my students wrote his Master's Thesis about performance of > VPN gateways.> The thesis features a performance comparison > between Wireguard, OpenVPN, and Linux IPsec. He also implemented > several different possible architectures for VPN gateways and draws > some conclusions about possible improvements in Wireguard. > > Like most good theses it was written under time pressure close to > the deadline, so there are some rough edges. Despite this I think > it's a quite excellent thesis that I'll be transforming it into a > (shorter) journal article later this year, but I've wanted to share > the thesis with you hoping that it's helpful or interesting for > some of you. One of the rough edges is that it refers to peer identities as Ed25519 public keys, but they are in fact Curve25519 public keys; WireGuard does not use an elliptic-curve signature scheme, but only elliptic-curve Diffie-Hellman-Merkle key agreement. - -- Aaron Jones -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - https://www.enigmail.net/ iQIzBAEBCgAdFiEEYKVBwe43zZh/jkxPivBzdIirMBIFAlyDYo8ACgkQivBzdIir MBLrkRAAmxm460mBaN/VYmHCG/brgJxkoISeAj2QT6n+8X39NbL+LZWN9A4ZYiP9 3VnGCK/NQH1UVwI3GElT5S1XV0gAYw+BGaSC9a7qBoE4Ks5WwnrZHl5cuejYTD+t uN6UOn0nQc5xyzCN++Da7cHJ2NbMOIHsTOTpApurmEMhpekSPtzZS4Px2OFEEmj1 R+1Sh+ygAEjVm8WjldLg+Uj1h/kybVvG8qlbe4ZSZinylM+k2qlfYdsZnttnjw7u if3L900m0IixDhxhvUZJ52rNL55B8iHSIWuyzrO+Ikb+e+/e8iIcVox1n7GNIE8L Vv1A+h55nsx1FFxNDWkTI5wGrg883HquIy5PH9AI4RWUK5ooDx/TJA04110dixIf PVpuh4gpAlLTWuXVkm5LzgJ7Ys5l+qQkao0YYV0TXQpVdfuWaD8exlKO5pyjYagN ppTsPIDh0Go2uVOUZuGzt3cCG8QHfrbo0xePWbQdc3PeMUbuDwU5aZoFmn2oHuWw UafH381nFUsH35fmXG67PcZ5gme91ZrtaKGEof3cu/+Ylv9HU0mh6MbBjVI9PtNf HD+FZF4FNUX6ekNf86mMgMSiONmzo+IcgjRwbfIT1p7AQ2Aox2D3jars/bD3q2/H ohUW/YlzgQF4AQQmQ9ekXYrpmfKczMbTkO9znyayMENDofuNSHk= =ukdC -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- _______________________________________________ WireGuard mailing list WireGuard@lists.zx2c4.com https://lists.zx2c4.com/mailman/listinfo/wireguard