Re: Can $_ substitute $0 when nofunctionargzero

[Sebastian Gniazdowski <sgniazdowski@gmail.com>]

On 9 June 2016 at 22:46, Bart Schaefer <schaefer@brasslantern.com> wrote:
> That should probably say "the environment of every external command"
> because the second part does not apply to builtins and subshells.

It is little hard to understand. For example something works in following:

local var="I am $_"
> I am local

Wonder if some nice trickery can be done with $_, maybe in patterns

> I had a bit of trouble untangling your "unless" clause there but if I
> understand you correctly then I don't think you've overlooked any
> other problems.

I thought about e.g.:

source "/path/plugin" color=red start_in_incremental_search

when sourcing some plugin – that what I meant by "parametrizing".

> At the risk of becoming one of PWS's second category of outraged frothy
> gibberers, there are already several other ways to obtain this:
>
>     $(print -P %N), which works for any zsh of the past 16 years
>     ${(%):-%N}, which has worked for the past 13 years
>     ${funcstack[1]} (or $funcstack[0] if ksharrays), somewhat newer

That's just great, thanks! I already added "0=${(%):-%N}" to my
plugins. Should have just asked earlier.

> If the concern (see discussion of add-zsh-hook-widget) is that plugins
> need to work arcoss a range of versions, then adding another builtin
> parameter is not going to be very useful.

Yeah I thought about future being sure there's no current remedy for
nofunctionargzero.

Best regards,
Sebastian Gniazdowski


On 9 June 2016 at 22:46, Bart Schaefer <schaefer@brasslantern.com> wrote:
> On Jun 9,  7:06pm, Sebastian Gniazdowski wrote:
> } Subject: Re: Can $_ substitute $0 when nofunctionargzero
> }
> } documentation says: "The  last  argument of the previous command.
> } Also, this parameter is set in the environment of every command
> } executed to the full pathname of the command."
>
> That should probably say "the environment of every external command"
> because the second part does not apply to builtins and subshells.
>
> } Turns out it's the first sentence that happens. Last argument to
> } `source' is substituted for $_. But in real word, $_ can still be used
> } when option functionargzero is unset, unless someone will came up with
> } a standard of how plugins can be parametrized - they're normally
> } sourced without any additional arguments.
> }
> } Any more flaws in this?
>
> I had a bit of trouble untangling your "unless" clause there but if I
> understand you correctly then I don't think you've overlooked any
> other problems.
>
> On Jun 9,  8:33pm, Sebastian Gniazdowski wrote:
> } Subject: Re: Can $_ substitute $0 when nofunctionargzero
> }
> } I read through discussion on ZSH_SCRIPT and ZSH_ARGZERO. Could there
> } be one more parameter added?
>
> At the risk of becoming one of PWS's second category of outraged frothy
> gibberers, there are already several other ways to obtain this:
>
>     $(print -P %N), which works for any zsh of the past 16 years
>     ${(%):-%N}, which has worked for the past 13 years
>     ${funcstack[1]} (or $funcstack[0] if ksharrays), somewhat newer
>
> (Not all versions that have $funcstack also treat "source" as a stack
> position, as I recall, though $funcstack has been around a long time.)
>
> If the concern (see discussion of add-zsh-hook-widget) is that plugins
> need to work arcoss a range of versions, then adding another builtin
> parameter is not going to be very useful.