On Wed, 14 Sep 2011, TJ Luoma wrote:

> I'm wondering if someone has already done this.
>
> I have a function which does this:
>
>
> move () {
> 	command which -s gmv
> 	if [ "$?" = "0" ]
> 	then
> 		gmv --verbose --backup=numbered $@
> 	else
> 		mv -v -i $@
> 	fi
> }
>
> (simply put: use 'gmv' if it exists, otherwise use 'mv')
>
> That works pretty well (although if there are ways to do it better, 
> please let me know).

There's a pretty common zsh idiom to avoid the use of 'which' or 'where':

(( $+commands[command-name] ))

So:

move () {
     if (( $+commands[gmv] )) ; then
         gmv --verbose --backup=numbered $@
     else
         mv -v -i $@
     fi
}

> HOWEVER, now I want to do
>
> "If $FILE is writable by $USER, do 'move' as above. ELSE use 'sudo' 
> before the mv or gmv command"
>
> I can probably cobble together a solution, but I thought I'd check 
> first to see if someone here had already invented this wheel.

For some things, I have it set up to:
1. try to do the thing
2. if it fails, try with sudo

E.g.:

mkdirp () { mkdir -p $argv || sudo mkdir -p $argv }

You get an extra warning when sudo's needed, but sometimes that's useful 
info.  And the code's pretty simple.  (Not sure why I prefer $argv over 
$@, exactly.)  Maybe dangerous in the case of a move (if some, but not 
all, of the files are successfully moved without sudo).


For this particular problem, maybe something along the lines of:

move () {
     local -a cmd

     # check that destination is writable
     # or destination doesn't exist, but its dir is writable
     # otherwise, need sudo
     [[ -w $argv[-1] ]] || [[ ( ! -e $argv[-1] ) && -w ${argv[-1]}:h ]] || cmd+=( sudo )

     if (( $+commands[gmv] )) ; then
         cmd+=( gmv --verbose --backup=numbered )
     else
         cmd+=( mv -v -i )
     fi

     $cmd $argv
}

In a lot of cases, I would probably shorten:

if (( $+commands[blah] )) ; then
     # x
else
     # y
fi

when x and y both always return true¹, to:

(( $+commands[blah] )) && x || y

But that makes for a pretty long line here:

(( $+commands[gmv] )) && cmd+=( gmv --verbose --backup=numbered ) || cmd+=( mv -v -i )

-- 
Best,
Ben

¹: for most values of "always"