[9fans] venti+fossil woes

[9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Christopher Nielsen]

fossil crashed in the middle of an archival snapshot.
now, i'm getting

err 4: no space left in arenas
failed to write lump for <vac score>: no space left in arenas

there's plenty of space left in the arenas. a whole other
167G disc, in fact.

i've run venti/checkarenas and venti/checkindex to fix any
inconsistencies. they were both successful according to the
output.

any ideas about what is going on and how to fix it?

also, is there any way to tell fossil to stop trying to do
the snapshot?

--
Christopher Nielsen
"They who can give up essential liberty for temporary
safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Geoff Collyer]

Venti may be fine, but fossil need not be.  What does

	flchk -f /dev/sdXX/fossil	# where sdXX is your fossil disk

say?

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Christopher Nielsen]

On Fri, Nov 14, 2003 at 03:23:03PM -0800, Geoff Collyer wrote:
> Venti may be fine, but fossil need not be.  What does
>
> 	flchk -f /dev/sdXX/fossil	# where sdXX is your fossil disk
>
> say?

gives me a huge list of bfree commands

--
Christopher Nielsen
"They who can give up essential liberty for temporary
safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Charles Forsyth]

>>here's plenty of space left in the arenas. a whole other
>>167G disc, in fact.

i wonder whether something in the mix can't cope
correctly with a disc that size

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Christopher Nielsen]

On Fri, Nov 14, 2003 at 11:37:55PM +0000, Charles Forsyth wrote:
>
> i wonder whether something in the mix can't cope
> correctly with a disc that size

it's been coping just fine for the last three months.
the first disc of arenas is 167G, too.

before i wrote the 48-bit lba support for the ata driver,
it wouldn't recognise the upper part of the disc.

--
Christopher Nielsen
"They who can give up essential liberty for temporary
safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[boyd, rounin]

> i wonder whether something in the mix can't cope
> correctly with a disc that size

that could be it.  any extensible system must cope with
stuff that's larger than it expects.  in that case it should
say _immediately_:

    i can't cope with that

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Charles Forsyth]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 245 bytes --]

i know you did that, but
i suppose i meant: in the code of one or both of them,
somewhere it stores a value shorter than it ought to be,
and it's only noticed when allocation moves into the given region.
how big are the various partitions?

[-- Attachment #2: Type: message/rfc822, Size: 2737 bytes --]

From: Christopher Nielsen <cnielsen@pobox.com>
To: 9fans@cse.psu.edu
Subject: Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes
Date: Fri, 14 Nov 2003 15:43:03 -0800
Message-ID: <20031114234303.GE834@cassie.foobarbaz.net>

On Fri, Nov 14, 2003 at 11:37:55PM +0000, Charles Forsyth wrote:
>
> i wonder whether something in the mix can't cope
> correctly with a disc that size

it's been coping just fine for the last three months.
the first disc of arenas is 167G, too.

before i wrote the 48-bit lba support for the ata driver,
it wouldn't recognise the upper part of the disc.

--
Christopher Nielsen
"They who can give up essential liberty for temporary
safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Christopher Nielsen]

On Sat, Nov 15, 2003 at 12:17:38AM +0000, Charles Forsyth wrote:
> i know you did that, but

right. sorry.

> i suppose i meant: in the code of one or both of them,
> somewhere it stores a value shorter than it ought to be,
> and it's only noticed when allocation moves into the given region.
> how big are the various partitions?

i understand what you're saying, now.

the arena partitions take up the whole of both 167G discs.
the arenas are (the default) 512M. fossil is on a 74G
partition, and the venti index is on a 18G partititon.

the arena it's trying to write to is 312 out of 670. the
amount of data currently in the venti is ~155G.

--
Christopher Nielsen
"They who can give up essential liberty for temporary
safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Christopher Nielsen]

Here's an update for anyone interested, since I can't
manage to get to sleep for some reason.

I bought some better quality ata cables yesterday. That
helped to the point that I thought my troubles were over.
No such luck.

Now, what I am seeing is whenever a venti arena becomes
full and is in the process of being sealed, the screen
becomes filled with IBsy+ repeated ad infinitum, which
I know is from the ata driver. Eventually, fossil gives
an error from diskReadRaw() saying something like:

archive(0, <block addr>): cannot find block: i/o error

followed by a dump that I presume could be useful for
diagnostics.

What I am guessing is happening is that there is so much
contention in the controller that it's causing reads and
sometimes writes to timeout. This eventually causes fossil
to just fall over dead. At which point, I reboot from a
CD, run venti/checkarenas -vf on the arena partition and
then reboot so that fossil can continue where it left off
with the snapshot.

Wash, rinse, repeat.

Anyway, the saga continues. We'll see if I end up losing
data. I'm still guessing not. My only comment is that it
would be nice if fossil would handle such error conditions
more gracefully.

Regardless, I am going to dig around for another ata
controller to spread the disks across.

On Sat, Nov 15, 2003 at 05:37:57PM -0800, Christopher Nielsen wrote:
> this is looking more and more like it was a hardware
> problem. reseating all the connections eliminated most
> of the errors i was seeing. now i am getting errors
> from diskRawWrite, which leads me to believe that one
> of the disks is going bad. i can't really tell which
> one, though. the error message from diskRawWrite gives
> some diagnostic info, but i don't know how to interpret
> it. admittedly, i haven't dived into the source as much
> as i could, but maybe someone can provide some insight
> before i go ahead and do that.
>
> thanks to everyone that has provided input so far.
>
> i have to say, it doesn't look like i'm going to lose
> any data. it's not certain yet, but it's looking good.
> the paranoia in fossil and venti are good.
>
> On Fri, Nov 14, 2003 at 03:18:42PM -0800, Christopher Nielsen wrote:
> > fossil crashed in the middle of an archival snapshot.
> > now, i'm getting
> >
> > err 4: no space left in arenas
> > failed to write lump for <vac score>: no space left in arenas
> >
> > there's plenty of space left in the arenas. a whole other
> > 167G disc, in fact.
> >
> > i've run venti/checkarenas and venti/checkindex to fix any
> > inconsistencies. they were both successful according to the
> > output.
> >
> > any ideas about what is going on and how to fix it?
> >
> > also, is there any way to tell fossil to stop trying to do
> > the snapshot?
>
> --
> Christopher Nielsen
> "They who can give up essential liberty for temporary
> safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin

--
Christopher Nielsen
"They who can give up essential liberty for temporary
safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Russ Cox]

Have you tried replacing the disk?  Since only one disk I/O
is done at a time, I have a hard time believing that contention
is causing them to time out.  Contention might cause them to
take a while before they acquire the lock around the disk,
but that isn't timed.

Russ

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Charles Forsyth]

it's probably just me, but i nearly always
suspect software rather than hardware, until
i'm absolutely sure (i have seen some botched
hardware though).  i wonder whether
the iBsy+ isn't a clue: it has got an interrupt,
but the device is busy when the interrupt function
starts, and it seems to happen (after some point)
under load.  is the interrupt shared?
are rwm and dma set?

Re: SPAM: Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[jmk]

On Tue Nov 18 07:41:46 EST 2003, cnielsen@pobox.com wrote:
> ...
>
> Now, what I am seeing is whenever a venti arena becomes
> full and is in the process of being sealed, the screen
> becomes filled with IBsy+ repeated ad infinitum, which
> I know is from the ata driver. Eventually, fossil gives
> an error from diskReadRaw() saying something like:
>
> ...
>

I'd say that still points to a hardware problem. Can you tell
us what
	ATA controller (or which chipset it is in)
	drive model numbers
	the 'dev' lines printed at kernel boot for the drives
are?

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Christopher Nielsen]

On Tue, Nov 18, 2003 at 09:08:49AM -0500, Russ Cox wrote:
> Have you tried replacing the disk?  Since only one disk I/O
> is done at a time, I have a hard time believing that contention
> is causing them to time out.  Contention might cause them to
> take a while before they acquire the lock around the disk,
> but that isn't timed.

Changing the disk, currently, is not an option. There's
still data being written from fossil to venti from an
archival snapshot that starts up every time the machine
boots, albeit slowly and interspersed with fossil crashes.

On Tue, Nov 18, 2003 at 03:27:00PM +0000, Charles Forsyth wrote:
> it's probably just me, but i nearly always
> suspect software rather than hardware, until
> i'm absolutely sure (i have seen some botched
> hardware though).  i wonder whether
> the iBsy+ isn't a clue: it has got an interrupt,
> but the device is busy when the interrupt function
> starts, and it seems to happen (after some point)
> under load.  is the interrupt shared?
> are rwm and dma set?

I don't think the interrupt is shared. Both dma and rwm
are set for all the drives.

On Tue, Nov 18, 2003 at 10:36:55AM -0500, jmk@plan9.bell-labs.com wrote:
>
> I'd say that still points to a hardware problem. Can you tell
> us what
>       ATA controller (or which chipset it is in)
>       drive model numbers
>       the 'dev' lines printed at kernel boot for the drives are?

The controller is a Promise 100TX2 (PDC20268).

The drives are all Western Digital:
	2x WD1800JB venti arenas
	1x WD800JB fossil
	1x WD400JB venti index

The 'dev' lines from boot:
dev A0 port CCD8 config 427A capabilities 2F00 mwdma 0007 udma 203F
dev B0 port CCD8 config 427A capabilities 2F00 mwdma 0007 udma 203F
dev A0 port CCC0 config 427A capabilities 2F00 mwdma 0007 udma 203F
dev B0 port CCC0 config 427A capabilities 2F00 mwdma 0007 udma 203F

Thanks for the help/input, guys.

--
Christopher Nielsen
"They who can give up essential liberty for temporary
safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[jmk]

On Tue Nov 18 17:36:41 EST 2003, cnielsen@pobox.com wrote:
> ...
> I don't think the interrupt is shared. Both dma and rwm
> are set for all the drives.
> ...
cat '#P/irqalloc'
should tell you.

> ...
> The controller is a Promise 100TX2 (PDC20268).
> ...
Does anyone know if this works properly? I know the driver
will recognise it, but are there any bugs/workarounds for this
chip we are missing?

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[mirtchov]

> Does anyone know if this works properly? I know the driver
> will recognise it, but are there any bugs/workarounds for this
> chip we are missing?

Mine is a Promise 20378.  I've had no problems of the sort Chris is
reporting.

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Christopher Nielsen]

On Tue, Nov 18, 2003 at 06:10:06PM -0500, jmk@plan9.bell-labs.com wrote:
> cat '#P/irqalloc'
> should tell you.

ah great. thanks.

#nidaba cat '#P/irqalloc'
	 3	 0 debugpt
	 7	 0 mathemu
	 8	 0 doublefault
	 9	 0 mathover
	14	 0 fault386
	16	 0 matherror
	32	 0 clock
	33	 1 kbd
	36	 4 COM1
	38	 6 floppy
	41	 9 sdF (ata)
	41	 9 sdE (ata)
	43	11 usb0
	43	11 ether0
	47	15 sdD (ata)

So it looks like the controllers for the four disks are
sharing an interrupt. That could be a problem...

> > ...
> > The controller is a Promise 100TX2 (PDC20268).
> > ...
> Does anyone know if this works properly? I know the driver
> will recognise it, but are there any bugs/workarounds for this
> chip we are missing?

That was one of the first things I started to look into. I
didn't see anything unusual in the FreeBSD ata driver that
would indicate it has troubles. But I did see some possible
problems when I did a google search. I haven't had the time
to dive into it in enough detail. I'll see if I can find
anything useful.

--
Christopher Nielsen
"They who can give up essential liberty for temporary
safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Geoff Collyer]

Wow, your irqalloc output is already sorted; I have to sort mine by
hand.

It seems odd that sdC doesn't show up (at irq 14).  I only have one
CPU server with IDE disk(s), but its irqs look like this:

; sort +1nb  '#P/irqalloc'
          3           0 debugpt
          7           0 mathemu
          8           0 doublefault
          9           0 mathover
         14           0 fault386
         16           0 matherror
         32           0 clock
         33           1 kbd
         38           6 floppy
         42          10 ether1
         44          12 ether0
         46          14 sdC (ata)
         47          15 sdD (ata)

You've got sdE and sdF sharing irq 9 and usb0 and ether0 sharing irq
11 (yet irqs 10 and 12 are unused).  This could be due to a buggy BIOS
(I've got a few of those), but more likely your BIOS is running out of
irqs that it knows to be free and thus doubles up devices.  It would
be worthwhile to go into BIOS setup and disable any devices you aren't
using, to reclaim their IRQs.  Also visit your PCI/PNP assignment
screen and let PCI/PNP have all free irqs, or turn off manual
selection of free irqs.

On a CPU server, you can probably disable all LPT (parallel) ports at
irqs 5 and 7, COM2 (second serial port) at irq 3, and PS/2 mouse at
irq 12.  If you're not using USB, don't assign it an irq.  If there's
an option to assign your vga card an irq, disable it.  I'm not sure
what's sitting on irq 10; maybe vga.  Make sure your first IDE
controller is enabled (in your `integrated peripherals' screen); it
should appear at irq 14.

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[jmk]

On Tue Nov 18 18:31:43 EST 2003, cnielsen@pobox.com wrote:
> ...
> So it looks like the controllers for the four disks are
> sharing an interrupt. That could be a problem...
> ...

Sharing the interrupt should be be OK, but spitting out
the Ibsy message might confuse things enough to be a problem.
Disable that debug message in the driver.

Getting the controllers onto separate interrupts would help
in any case.

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Charles Forsyth]

>>Sharing the interrupt should be be OK, but spitting out
>>the Ibsy message might confuse things enough to be a problem.

it might delay the response to the IO request on the other
controller (which presumably caused the interrupt) long
enough for it to time out on occasion.

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Christopher Nielsen]

On Tue, Nov 18, 2003 at 03:59:15PM -0800, Geoff Collyer wrote:
> Wow, your irqalloc output is already sorted; I have to sort mine by
> hand.

Well, it was transcribed by hand, but it was transcribed
exactly as I saw it.

> It seems odd that sdC doesn't show up (at irq 14).

When you consider that there isn't a drive on sdC, it's
not so odd.

> I only have one CPU server with IDE disk(s), but its irqs look like this:
>
> ; sort +1nb  '#P/irqalloc'
>           3           0 debugpt
>           7           0 mathemu
>           8           0 doublefault
>           9           0 mathover
>          14           0 fault386
>          16           0 matherror
>          32           0 clock
>          33           1 kbd
>          38           6 floppy
>          42          10 ether1
>          44          12 ether0
>          46          14 sdC (ata)
>          47          15 sdD (ata)
>
> You've got sdE and sdF sharing irq 9 and usb0 and ether0 sharing irq
> 11 (yet irqs 10 and 12 are unused).  This could be due to a buggy BIOS
> (I've got a few of those), but more likely your BIOS is running out of
> irqs that it knows to be free and thus doubles up devices.  It would
> be worthwhile to go into BIOS setup and disable any devices you aren't
> using, to reclaim their IRQs.  Also visit your PCI/PNP assignment
> screen and let PCI/PNP have all free irqs, or turn off manual
> selection of free irqs.

sdE and sdF are where all the drives doing all the i/o
are living, so it's no wonder there are problems, since
they're all sharing an interrupt.

Unfortunately, the BIOS setup for this particular machine
(an old Dell optiplex) seems mostly neutered. You can't do
anything you describe. Considering it's a Dell, I am leaning
very heavily toward buggy BIOS. I have an extra case and
(decent) motherboard that I can moves the entire system to,
so I think I will try that and see if I get more reasonable
behavior.

Never send a desktop to do a server's work. *sigh*

> On a CPU server, you can probably disable all LPT (parallel) ports at
> irqs 5 and 7, COM2 (second serial port) at irq 3, and PS/2 mouse at
> irq 12.  If you're not using USB, don't assign it an irq.  If there's
> an option to assign your vga card an irq, disable it.  I'm not sure
> what's sitting on irq 10; maybe vga.  Make sure your first IDE
> controller is enabled (in your `integrated peripherals' screen); it
> should appear at irq 14.

Yeah, I usually disable any devices that I have no use for
on a server system, pretty much including everything you've
listed.

Thanks!

--
Christopher Nielsen
"They who can give up essential liberty for temporary
safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[okamoto]

> anything you describe. Considering it's a Dell, I am leaning
> very heavily toward buggy BIOS. 

I cannot set the quantity of shared VGA memory on an old DELL Optiplex 
either.    I'm sick... ☺

Kenji

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Dan Cross]

Christopher Nielsen <cnielsen@pobox.com> writes:
> Unfortunately, the BIOS setup for this particular machine
> (an old Dell optiplex) seems mostly neutered. You can't do
> anything you describe. Considering it's a Dell, I am leaning
> very heavily toward buggy BIOS. I have an extra case and
> (decent) motherboard that I can moves the entire system to,
> so I think I will try that and see if I get more reasonable
> behavior.
>
> Never send a desktop to do a server's work. *sigh*

Dude!  You got screwed by a Dell!!

	- Dan C.

(Okay, sorry; I realize this must be frustrating, and I mean no
animosity, but I couldn't resist the illusion to the infamous
``Dell Dude.'')

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Christopher Nielsen]

On Tue, Nov 18, 2003 at 11:51:50PM -0500, Dan Cross wrote:
> Christopher Nielsen <cnielsen@pobox.com> writes:
> > Unfortunately, the BIOS setup for this particular machine
> > (an old Dell optiplex) seems mostly neutered. You can't do
> > anything you describe. Considering it's a Dell, I am leaning
> > very heavily toward buggy BIOS. I have an extra case and
> > (decent) motherboard that I can moves the entire system to,
> > so I think I will try that and see if I get more reasonable
> > behavior.
> >
> > Never send a desktop to do a server's work. *sigh*
>
> Dude!  You got screwed by a Dell!!

Hah!

> (Okay, sorry; I realize this must be frustrating, and I mean no
> animosity, but I couldn't resist the illusion to the infamous
> ``Dell Dude.'')

Yes, very frustrating, and I know you mean no animosity.
Humor is good at times like these.
Thanks. :)

--
Christopher Nielsen
"They who can give up essential liberty for temporary
safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Christopher Nielsen]

Well, it appears to be fixed. For reasons that aren't
important, I wasn't able to put the system on a different
motherboard, so i did the next best thing. i put fossil
and isect on the onboard controller so all disks wouldn't
be sharing an interrupt. So far, no errors whatsoever.
the transfer rate isn't as high because the onboard ata
controller isn't ata100, but at least it appears stable.

I'm going to let it run for a while to make sure it's
happy, and if anything changes, I'll let you know.

The moral of this story, don't share interrupts with
fossil and venti on multiple disks.

Thank you very much to everyone that offered up advice
and help.

--
Christopher Nielsen
"They who can give up essential liberty for temporary
safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[C H Forsyth]

>>The moral of this story, don't share interrupts with
>>fossil and venti on multiple disks.

i think the moral is that something is wrong that
prevents that.  i think it ought to work.
it's not an uncommon arrangement.

did you try disabling the IBsy+ print before you
moved the drives, and if so did it make no difference.

Re: [9fans] venti+fossil woes

[Christopher Nielsen]

On Thu, Nov 20, 2003 at 09:26:07AM +0000, C H Forsyth wrote:
>
> i think the moral is that something is wrong that
> prevents that.  i think it ought to work.
> it's not an uncommon arrangement.

that was my point, even if i didn't state it directly.
i think it ought to work too, but for some reason it
does not. i'm willing to investigate.

> did you try disabling the IBsy+ print before you
> moved the drives, and if so did it make no difference.

i didn't. mostly because i didn't have the time. for
the sake of experiment and improving plan 9, i may have
some time to try that on friday. as it stands, i have
still not seen any errors.

--
Christopher Nielsen
"They who can give up essential liberty for temporary
safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin