* 0.13: nneething doesn't recognize mailbox files?
@ 1997-11-09 15:33 Jari Aalto
1997-11-13 21:24 ` Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen
0 siblings, 1 reply; 5+ messages in thread
From: Jari Aalto @ 1997-11-09 15:33 UTC (permalink / raw)
[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1023 bytes --]
Hi,
I fired up gnus to read bunch of mailbox files from procmail
mailing lists and I was suprised that gnus didn't recognize
the files as mailboxes (no threading). I took couple of files
and -head 300 to test this in clean directory. This is std
0.13 with default settings (No personal .gnus used).
Any ideas? Is the file format somehow wrong?
jari
The test dir:
pegasus nne % pwd; ll
/tmp_mnt/users/jaalto/tmp/gnus/nne
drwxr-xr-x 2 jaalto nms 96 Nov 9 17:24 .
-rw-r--r-- 1 jaalto nms 13870 Nov 9 17:24 1995-11.mbox
-rw-r--r-- 1 jaalto nms 12262 Nov 9 17:23 1995-10.mbox
drwxr-xr-x 3 jaalto nms 96 Nov 9 17:23 ..
The Group buffer:
4: nneething+~/tmp/gnus/nne:gnus-test-nne
The Summary Buffer:
[ 0: Jari Aalto ] .
[ 0: Jari Aalto ] ..
[ 0: Paul Murphy ] procmail, comsat, and me.
[ 0: Fu Bar ] Re: [Linux-ISP] Re: checking logins for pop3
And the files follow:
[-- Attachment #2: 1995-10.mbox --]
[-- Type: application/octet-stream, Size: 5788 bytes --]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[-- Attachment #3: Type: text/plain, Size: 1 bytes --]
[-- Attachment #4: 1995-11.mbox --]
[-- Type: application/octet-stream, Size: 0 bytes --]
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread
* Re: 0.13: nneething doesn't recognize mailbox files?
1997-11-09 15:33 0.13: nneething doesn't recognize mailbox files? Jari Aalto
@ 1997-11-13 21:24 ` Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen
1997-11-16 22:15 ` jari.aalto
0 siblings, 1 reply; 5+ messages in thread
From: Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen @ 1997-11-13 21:24 UTC (permalink / raw)
Jari Aalto <jari.aalto@ntc.nokia.com> writes:
> I fired up gnus to read bunch of mailbox files from procmail
> mailing lists and I was suprised that gnus didn't recognize
> the files as mailboxes (no threading). I took couple of files
> and -head 300 to test this in clean directory. This is std
> 0.13 with default settings (No personal .gnus used).
[...]
> [ 0: Paul Murphy ] procmail, comsat, and me.
> [ 0: Fu Bar ] Re: [Linux-ISP] Re: checking logins for pop3
It seems to me that nneething recognized that these were mail messages
-- how could it otherwise pick out the subject and stuff? I think you
may be confused as to what the purpose of nneething is -- it is not to
read collections of mailboxes; it is to read collections of arbitrary
files. Each file gets one line in the summary buffer.
--
(domestic pets only, the antidote for overdose, milk.)
larsi@gnus.org * Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread
* Re: 0.13: nneething doesn't recognize mailbox files?
1997-11-13 21:24 ` Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen
@ 1997-11-16 22:15 ` jari.aalto
1997-11-17 17:52 ` Justin Sheehy
1997-11-23 6:02 ` Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen
0 siblings, 2 replies; 5+ messages in thread
From: jari.aalto @ 1997-11-16 22:15 UTC (permalink / raw)
| 97-11-13 Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen <larsi@gnus.org> list.ding
|
| > I fired up gnus to read bunch of mailbox files from procmail
| > mailing lists and I was suprised that gnus didn't recognize
| > the files as mailboxes (no threading). I took couple of files
| > and -head 300 to test this in clean directory. This is std
| > 0.13 with default settings (No personal .gnus used).
|
| [...]
|
| > [ 0: Paul Murphy ] procmail, comsat, and me.
| > [ 0: Fu Bar ] Re: [Linux-ISP] Re: checking logins for pop3
|
| It seems to me that nneething recognized that these were mail messages
| -- how could it otherwise pick out the subject and stuff? I think you
| may be confused as to what the purpose of nneething is -- it is not to
| read collections of mailboxes; it is to read collections of arbitrary
| files. Each file gets one line in the summary buffer.
Okay. Clear now. Would it be possible to add a command to nneething
as:
"When I press key X, spool this nneething file as mailbox and allow
me to read it with threading"
The I could browse the a directory with many mailboxes easily.
I guess now I make nndoc for each of these list messages.
jari
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread
* Re: 0.13: nneething doesn't recognize mailbox files?
1997-11-16 22:15 ` jari.aalto
@ 1997-11-17 17:52 ` Justin Sheehy
1997-11-23 6:02 ` Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen
1 sibling, 0 replies; 5+ messages in thread
From: Justin Sheehy @ 1997-11-17 17:52 UTC (permalink / raw)
<jari.aalto@poboxes.com> writes:
> Okay. Clear now. Would it be possible to add a command to nneething
> as:
>
> "When I press key X, spool this nneething file as mailbox and allow
> me to read it with threading"
>
> The I could browse the a directory with many mailboxes easily.
I will repeat what Lars said: nnething is not designed for reading
collections of mailboxes. It is designed for reading collections of
arbitrary files. Adding such format-specificness is contrary to its
purpose.
If you want to read such a collection, make a group for each
collection of mailboxes (nndoc, nnfolder, whatever) and then make an
nnvirtual group containing them all.
--
Justin Sheehy
In a cloud bones of steel.
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread
* Re: 0.13: nneething doesn't recognize mailbox files?
1997-11-16 22:15 ` jari.aalto
1997-11-17 17:52 ` Justin Sheehy
@ 1997-11-23 6:02 ` Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen
1 sibling, 0 replies; 5+ messages in thread
From: Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen @ 1997-11-23 6:02 UTC (permalink / raw)
<jari.aalto@poboxes.com> writes:
> Okay. Clear now. Would it be possible to add a command to nneething
> as:
>
> "When I press key X, spool this nneething file as mailbox and allow
> me to read it with threading"
No, that can't be added to nneething. Since Gnus already has `C-d'
(and family), there's not much point.
--
(domestic pets only, the antidote for overdose, milk.)
larsi@gnus.org * Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 5+ messages in thread
end of thread, other threads:[~1997-11-23 6:02 UTC | newest]
Thread overview: 5+ messages (download: mbox.gz / follow: Atom feed)
-- links below jump to the message on this page --
1997-11-09 15:33 0.13: nneething doesn't recognize mailbox files? Jari Aalto
1997-11-13 21:24 ` Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen
1997-11-16 22:15 ` jari.aalto
1997-11-17 17:52 ` Justin Sheehy
1997-11-23 6:02 ` Lars Magne Ingebrigtsen
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox;
as well as URLs for NNTP newsgroup(s).